diff --git a/CMakeLists.txt b/CMakeLists.txt
index 0b28fef3..914e3054 100644
--- a/CMakeLists.txt
+++ b/CMakeLists.txt
@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ option(JAPANESE "Enable the Japanese-language build" OFF)
 option(FIX_BUGS "Fix various bugs in the game" OFF)
 option(DEBUG_SAVE "Re-enable the ability to drag-and-drop save files onto the window" OFF)
 option(FORCE_LOCAL_LIBS "Compile the built-in versions of SDL2, FreeType, and FLTK instead of using the system-provided ones" OFF)
-set(RENDERER "Texture" CACHE STRING "Which renderer the game should use: 'OpenGL3' for an OpenGL 3.2 renderer, 'Texture' for SDL2's hardware-accelerated Texture API, 'Surface' for SDL2's software-rendered Surface API, or 'Software' for a handwritten software renderer")
+set(RENDERER "Texture" CACHE STRING "Which renderer the game should use: 'OpenGL3' for an OpenGL 3.2 renderer, 'SDLTexture' for SDL2's hardware-accelerated Texture API, 'SDLSurface' for SDL2's software-rendered Surface API, or 'Software' for a handwritten software renderer")
 
 project(CSE2 LANGUAGES C CXX)
 
@@ -249,9 +249,9 @@ endif()
 
 if(RENDERER MATCHES "OpenGL3")
 	target_sources(CSE2 PRIVATE "src/Backends/Rendering/OpenGL3.cpp")
-elseif(RENDERER MATCHES "Texture")
+elseif(RENDERER MATCHES "SDLTexture")
 	target_sources(CSE2 PRIVATE "src/Backends/Rendering/SDLTexture.cpp")
-elseif(RENDERER MATCHES "Surface")
+elseif(RENDERER MATCHES "SDLSurface")
 	target_sources(CSE2 PRIVATE "src/Backends/Rendering/SDLSurface.cpp")
 elseif(RENDERER MATCHES "Software")
 	target_sources(CSE2 PRIVATE "src/Backends/Rendering/Software.cpp")
diff --git a/Makefile b/Makefile
index 47f51441..7fcd7b34 100644
--- a/Makefile
+++ b/Makefile
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ BUILD_DIRECTORY = game
 ASSETS_DIRECTORY = assets
 
 # Default options
-RENDERER ?= Texture
+RENDERER ?= SDLTexture
 
 ifeq ($(WINDOWS), 1)
 	EXE_EXTENSION = .exe
@@ -216,9 +216,9 @@ ifeq ($(RENDERER), OpenGL3)
 	else
 		LIBS += -lGL
 	endif
-else ifeq ($(RENDERER), Texture)
+else ifeq ($(RENDERER), SDLTexture)
 	SOURCES += src/Backends/Rendering/SDLTexture
-else ifeq ($(RENDERER), Surface)
+else ifeq ($(RENDERER), SDLSurface)
 	SOURCES += src/Backends/Rendering/SDLSurface
 else ifeq ($(RENDERER), Software)
 	SOURCES += src/Backends/Rendering/Software
diff --git a/README.md b/README.md
index 21349230..3bd92a24 100644
--- a/README.md
+++ b/README.md
@@ -64,8 +64,8 @@ Name | Function
 `-DDEBUG_SAVE=ON` | Re-enable the ability to drag-and-drop save files onto the window
 `-DFORCE_LOCAL_LIBS=ON` | Compile the built-in versions of SDL2, FreeType, and FLTK instead of using the system-provided ones
 `-DRENDERER=OpenGL3` | Use the hardware-accelerated OpenGL 3.2 renderer
-`-DRENDERER=Texture` | Use the hardware-accelerated SDL2 Texture API renderer (default)
-`-DRENDERER=Surface` | Use the software-rendered SDL2 Surface API renderer
+`-DRENDERER=SDLTexture` | Use the hardware-accelerated SDL2 Texture API renderer (default)
+`-DRENDERER=SDLSurface` | Use the software-rendered SDL2 Surface API renderer
 `-DRENDERER=Software` | Use the handwritten software renderer
 
 Then compile CSE2 with this command:
@@ -93,8 +93,8 @@ Name | Function
 `WINDOWS=1` | Build for Windows
 `DEBUG_SAVE=1` | Re-enable the ability to drag-and-drop save files onto the window
 `RENDERER=OpenGL3` | Use the hardware-accelerated OpenGL 3.2 renderer
-`RENDERER=Texture` | Use the hardware-accelerated SDL2 Texture API renderer (default)
-`RENDERER=Surface` | Use the software-rendered SDL2 Surface API renderer
+`RENDERER=SDLTexture` | Use the hardware-accelerated SDL2 Texture API renderer (default)
+`RENDERER=SDLSurface` | Use the software-rendered SDL2 Surface API renderer
 `RENDERER=Software` | Use the hand-written software renderer
 
 Once built, the executables and assets can be found in the newly-generated `game` folder.